|
|
Collectibles have beaten the S&P 500 for 20 years — almost no one holding them captured that return. |
|
One Number
$1 million invested in the Knight Frank Luxury Investment Index (KFLII) in 2005 returned $5.4 million by the end of 2024. Similar investment in the S&P 500 returned $5 million over the same period. Knight Frank Wealth Report 2025 That 20-year record looks like a clean case for diversification — until you ask which collectors actually earned it, and which categories did all the work. |
|
|
One Argument Collectibles have quietly beaten the stock market for twenty years — and almost none of that return belongs to the person who isn't already an expert.The KFLII’s 20-year outperformance of the S&P 500 is genuine. However, the index is a weighted basket of 10 categories. The return is an average across the market where performance has diverged by asset and by timing. To illustrate, in 2024 alone, five of ten categories declined, according to Knight Frank Wealth Report 2025. Handbags increased 2.8% and watches 1.7%, while art was down 18.3% and whisky down 9%. A portfolio built from a few items could just as easily outperform or underperform the index by a wide margin. Knight Frank has concluded in its 2025 report that “scarcity no longer guarantees returns”. The market is shifting toward narrative and provenance. This increases the importance of having an analytical edge to pick winners. Meanwhile, the combination of passion and investment that served as a driver for most collectors has decreased from 76% in 2014 to 59% in 2025, according to Deloitte Private/ArtTactic Art & Finance Report 2025. Collectibles come with a cost. Authentication, storage, insurance and maintenance are real carrying costs that have no equivalent for other asset classes. Unlike a coupon or dividend, collectibles generate no income stream to offset those costs while you hold them. The mid-market segment (works priced between $50,000 and $1 million) where a generalist investor could plausibly transact represented about $8 billion in global auction sales in 2024, or just 4% of lots sold, according to the Deloitte Private/ArtTactic Art & Finance Report 2025. The other 96% of the market has no continuous bid, no benchmark index, and no public pricing. Blue chip categories have institutionalised to the point that even an informed amateur, not at all a specialist, can transact in confidence, because they now trade on near-continuous secondary markets with public benchmark pricing. The Patek Philippe Market Index increased 12.1% in 2025, while Rolex Market Index grew 4.6%, according to Knight Frank’s Wealth Report 2026. Both came out well ahead of inflation. For those collectors willing to stay inside the names with established indices and deep trading volume the expertise barrier is really shrinking. But that confidence is specific to watches — the same ten-category basket includes art and wine, which the divergence data above show behaved nothing like a liquid, transparently-priced market in 2024.
|
|
One Position Treat the liquid benchmarked names as a defensive holding at best. It is not the source of alpha by the time a non-specialist can identify it. Everything else can be entered only with genuine domain knowledge. Without that the return is the S&P 500 minus liquidity, minus yield, plus expertise risk. This position changes if wealth managers' retreat from the category reverses — that withdrawal, not any new stability in pricing, is why no one is going to price the risk honestly for you in the meantime. If you had to sell the most valuable thing you own outside your house, your car and your portfolio within 30 days - do you actually know who would buy it? |
|
If this was forwarded to you and you'd like to receive Corporate Financier's Notes every Thursday, you can subscribe here. Reading on your phone? Tap the three dots or overflow menu in the top corner of your email app and select View in browser for the best experience.
|